 | United States. Supreme Court - 1906 - 724 halaman
...limitations upon this power require it to rest upon some difference, bearing a just and reasonable relation to the act in respect to which the classification is proposed, and it is enough that there is no discrimination in favor of one as against another of the same class.... | |
 | United States. Supreme Court - 1906 - 726 halaman
...limitations upon this power require it to rest upon some difference, bearing a just and reasonable relation to the act in respect to which the classification is proposed, and it is enough that there is no discrimination in favor of one as against another of the same class.... | |
 | 1907 - 854 halaman
...business could not so sue; in other words, to permit a classification based on ' some difference bearing a reasonable and just relation to the act in respect to which the classification is proposed.' (Ellis' Case, 165 US 150, 17 Sup. Ct. 225, 41 L. Ed. 666.) " Section 103 was itself a special classification... | |
 | 1907 - 1076 halaman
...sue; In other words, to permit a classification based on 'some difference bearing a reasonable aud Just relation to the act In respect to which the classification Is proposed." Ellis' Case, 105 US 150, 17 Sup. Ct 255, 41 L. Ed. 666. The use of the word 'class' In the last clause... | |
 | United States. Congress. House. Committee on Labor - 1908 - 1016 halaman
...conditions, as the State may legally prescribe. Tin1 difficulty is not met by saying that, cent-rally speaking, the State when enacting laws may, in its...in respect to which the classification is proposed, anil can never be made arbitrarily and without any such basis." We contend that there is no basis for... | |
 | Charles Louis McKeehan - 1908 - 30 halaman
...regulation can have is to protect the public right to reasonable rates. It is equally clear that a classification must always rest upon some difference...in respect to which the classification is proposed. How can it be said that the classification made by this statute bears a reasonable relation to the... | |
 | Abraham Clark Freeman - 1908 - 1208 halaman
...Sup. Ct. Rep. 255, 41 L. ed. 666, decides that the classification must not be arbitrary — that is, "must always rest upon some difference which bears...respect to which the classification is proposed"; also, that such classification must be "based upon some reasonable ground, some difference which bears... | |
 | 1908 - 1070 halaman
...classification for the purpose of special legislation of this kind must be based on "some difference bearing a reasonable and Just relation to the act in respect to which the classification is proposed." The court held that the fellow servant rule cannot be extended to corporations as such while at the... | |
 | William Mills Ivins, Herbert Delavan Mason - 1908 - 1242 halaman
...the right to classify for regulation, such classification must be based upon some difference bearing a reasonable and just relation to the act in respect to which the classification is attempted and no mere arbitrary selection can ever be justified by calling it classification.— A... | |
| |
For this court has held that classification " must always rest upon some difference which bears a reasonable and just relation to the act in respect to which the classification is proposed and can never be made arbitrarily and without any such basis. 
