which has the appearance of true submission, and is often mistaken for it, through the charity and fondness of friendship. But when the result is seen to uncertain, if there be, amid all the balancing of the mind between hope and fear, a willingness to acquiesce in the Supreme Will, there is good reason to believe that the patient has a true Christian resignation.

There was much force in the remark of a patient, who had for some days had the certain expectation of death, but who had at length experienced so much relief, that there was some ground for hope: "I am glad," said she, "that this relief has occurred, even if I do not recover; for now I can fairly test the reality of my submission. I can put life and death together, and examine my wishes and desires in regard to them."

There is one disease, in which the disposition to hope is so marked, that Dr. Good enumerates it among its symptoms. I refer to consumption. In some cases, it is true, this symptom does not appear; but despondency, for the most part, prevails: but this arises either from a morbid sensitiveness of the nervous system, or from a diseased condition of the digestive organs. When neither of these circumstances exists, and the disease is uncomplicated with other maladies, the tendency to hope is so strong as often to resist the force of the most decisive evidence.

Nothing is more common than to hear a consumptive patient say, "Doctor, if you will cure this cough, I shall be well;" as if the cough were only a slight matter, and its continuance was rather provoking than dangerous.

I once saw a Physician deceiving himself to the last week of his life with the idea, that his disease was in the stomach and liver, when there was the most palpable evidence that the lungs, and the lungs only, were diseased.

This tendency to hope is beautifully alluded to in a poetical sketch of consumption, by an anonymous author:

"Then came Consumption with her languid moods,
Her soothing whispers, and her dreams that seek
To muse themselves in silent solitudes :
She came with hectic glow, and wasted cheek,
And still the maiden pined more wan and weak,
Pale like the second bow: yet would she speak
The words of Hope, even while she passed away,
Amid the closing clouds, and faded ray by ray.”

Shall this hope, delusive as it so commonly is, be demolished by the Physician? Clearly it, in most cases at least, should not be; for in very many cases it manifestly prolongs life, and adds to its comfort and its usefulness, and, in some cases, it proves not to be

as delusive as perhaps even the Physician is disposed to consider it.

Recovery does now and then occur in cases of true consumption. The changes observed, by means of the stethoscope, in the progress of some cases which have ended in recovery, and the examinations of the lungs of those who have died of some other malady, show conclusively that tubercular consumption is not necessarily a fatal disease. Every Physician who has seen much of this disease, has occasionally witnessed facts confirmatory of this statement.*

In concluding this chapter, I remark, that the obvious rule in regard to the use to be made of hope as a curative agent is this-that its cordial influence should always be employed, so far as can be done consistently with truth, and no farther. And the bare fact, that a case has ended fatally, when the Physician has encouraged in the patient the hope of a recovery, should by no means, as is often done, be considered as proof that he has dealt falsely. He may have encouraged the patient

*The mortality of consumption has been undoubtedly increased by the very prevalent but erroneous opinion, that when this disease has once fairly begun, it is never arrested, but sooner or later ends in death. The definite opinions, too, sometimes given to the patient, as to the supposed hopelessness of the case, founded upon the revelations of the stethoscope, to the exclusion of other evidence, have produced the same effect.

in good faith. For the Physician, however wise and skilful he may be, is not able to foresee with any certainty the final event of sickness so frequently as is commonly supposed, and in all doubtful cases he is bound to give the patient the benefit of all the hope of which the symptoms will admit.

CHAPTER XII.

TRUTH IN OUR INTERCOURSE WITH THE SICK.

On the question, whether strict veracity should be adhered to, in every case and under all circumstances, in our intercourse with the sick, there is great difference of opinion, as well among medical men, as in the community at large. Some are most scrupulously strict in their regard to truth; others, while they are generally so, make some few occasional exceptions in cases of great emergency and necessity; while others give themselves great latitude in their practice, if they do not in their avowed opinions.

In examining this subject, it is not so much my intention to discuss the abstract question, as to present the many practical considerations that present themselves, illustrating them, so far as is necessary, by facts and cases.