OF THB SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES. FEBRUARY 3, 1896. FIRST CIRCUIT. Comprising Maine, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, and Rhode Islands JUSTICE HORACE GRAY, of Massachusetts. Appointed December 20, 1881, by Presca dent Arthur. SECOND CIRCUIT. Comprising Connecticut, New York, and Vermont. JUSTICE RUFUS W. PECKHAM, of New York. Appointed December 9, 1895, by Press ident Cleveland. THIRD CIRCUIT. Comprising Delaware, New Jersey, and Pennsyloanta. JUSTICE GEORGE SHIRAS, JR., of Pennsylvania. Appointed July 26, 1892, by Presle dent Harrison. FOURTH CIRCUIT. Comprising Maryland, North Carolina, South Carolina, Virginia, and West Virginia. CHIEF JUSTICE MELVILLE W. FULLER, of Illinois. Appointed July 20, 1888, by President Cleveland. FIFTH CIRCUIT. Comprising Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Louisiana, Mississippi, and Teras. JUSTICE EDWARD D. WHITE of Louisiana. Appointed February 19, 1894, by Pres ident Cleveland. SIXTH CIRCUIT. Comprising Kentucky, Michigan, Ohio, and Tennessee. JUSTICE JOHN M. HARLAN, of Kentucky. Appointed November 29, 1877, by Presi dent Hayes. SEVENTH CIRCUIT. Comprising Illinois, Indiana, and Wisconsin. JUSTICE HENRY BILLINGS BROWN, of Michigan. Appointed December 29, 1890, by President Harrison. EIGHTH CIRCUIT. Comprising Arkansas, Colorado, Iowa, Kansas, Minnesota, Missouri, Nebraska, North Dakota, South Dakota, and Wyoming. JUSTICE DAVID J. BREWER, of Kansas. Appointed December 18, 1889, by President Harrison. NINTH CIRCUIT. Comprising California, Idaho, Montana, Nevada, Oregon, and Washington. JUSTICE STEPHEN J. FIELD, of California. Appointed March 10, 1863, by President Lincolo. v.16 s. (iv). for cases reported in United States Reports 78 87 95 100 103 113 16 16 VOL. 159, UNITED STATES REPORTS. 8. Ct. U.S. Vol. Pg. | Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. 16 8. Ct. U. S. 8. Ct. U. 8. 8. Ct. U. 8. 8. Ct. U. 8. S. Ct. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. 15 1027 246 15 1037 255 15 1039 266 15 1038 293 16 80 477 16 15 997 247 15 1037 256 15 1040 266 15 1042 303 16 487 16 15 1018 247 15 1038 257 15 1040 267 15 1042 317 16 11 491 16 15 988 248 15 1038 258 15 15 1040 267 1043 327 16 15 500 15 1020 249 15 1038 258 15 1043 268 15 1043 332 16 87 510 15 1026 250 15 1037 259 15 1040 269 15 1043 349 16 17 523 994 250 15 1038 259 15 1041 269 15 1044 372 16 26 526 250 15 260 15 1040 270 15 1040 377 16 28 540 251 15 1038 260 15 1041 270 15 1044 380 16 991 251 15 1039 261 15 1041 271 15 1043 408 16 987 252 15 1038 262 15 1041 271 15 1044 415 16 29 252 15 1039 263 15 1041 272 1043 417 16 80 253 15 1039 263 15 1042 272 15 1044 423 16 139 253 15 1041 264 15 1042 275 320 452 16 171 254 15 1039 265 15 1 465 16 1037 15 15 985 1039 15 1002 15 43 541 16 1042 278 75 590 U. & Rep. 15 16 245 15 16 S. Ct. U. 8. 8. Ct. U. S. VOL. 160, UNITED STATES REPORTS. U. 8. 8. Ct. U. S. 8. Ct. U. S. 8. Ct. U. & 8. Ct. U. 8. S. Ct. U.S. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. 624 16 420 ÎÑÒÒÒÂÄ Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. | Pg. Vol. Pg. 1 16 190 136 16 247 231 16 297 319 16 288 394 16 360 514 16 879 53 16 210 149 16 225 247 16 291 327 16 307 408 16 327 531 16 366 643 16 431 70 16 216 170 16 321 259 16 269 355 16 321 426 16 322 546 16 877 646 16 417 77 16 231 171 16 258 268 16 294 357 16 834 438 16 838 553 16 888 654 16 415 101 16 239 187 16 263 276 16 278 369 16 370 452 16 845 556 16 8.89 660 16 412 103 16 219 203 16 252 288 16 276 374 16 818 469 16 853 584 16 373 668 16 427 110 16 240 217 16 272 293 16 304 379 16 849 493 16 371 593 16 886 686 16 433 121 16 222 221 16 273 303 16 282 389 16 344 499 16 897 598 16 402 688 16 433 128 16 244 16 16 16 16 VOL. 161, UNITED STATES REPORTS. Pg. Vol. Pg. 1 16 10 16 29 8. Ct. U.S. S. Ct. U. 8. S. Ct. U. 8. 8. Ct. U. S. 8. Ct. U. 8. 8. Ct. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. 439 96 16 506 186 16 468 246 16 502 346 16 485 451 16 618 545 16 621 443 101 16 492 193 16 466 247 16 523 350 16 454 459 16 516 573 16 663 16 434 101 16 508 193 16 471 256 16 585 355 16 490 475 16 641 583 16 611 480 104 16 532 198 16 468 275 16 502 359 16 526 483 16 631 588 16 610 487 115 16 537 198 16 476 291 16 495 375 16 592 499 16 637 591 16 644 134 16 456 200 16 450 297 16 476 397 16 571 500 16 640 639 16 694 497 149 16 558 200 16 476 306 508 412 16 576 502 16 689 642 16 693 554 161 16 461 208 564 434 16 483 173 16 466 235 16 29 16 16 16 488 16 16 16 16 544 316 16 613 513 16 637 646 16 705 512 446 16 562 519 16 600 677 16 714 16 493 174 16 471 240 16 500 VOL. 162, UNITED STATES REPORTS. U. 8. 8. Ct. U. S. 8. Ct. U. S. 8. Ct. U. 8. S. Ct. U. S. 8. Ct. U. S. 8. Ct. U. S. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. mñíðan Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. 1 16 725 283 16 828 339 16 850 410 16 797 435 16 799 499 16 864 602 16 875 16 802 439 16 853 512 16 885 613 16 895 16 848 415 16 803 466 16 859 529 16 879 625 16 952 16 831 419 16 804 478 16 871 547 16 890 650 16 934 16 814 4.20 16 798 490 16 869 565 16 904 664 16 943 91 16 766 290 16 796 346 16 843 411 167 16 794 291 16 820 359 170 16 695 313 16 839 366 184 16 700 324 16 801 383 923 197 16 666 326 16 795 399 16 837 425 16 805 498 16 871 592 16 900 687 16 16 754 329 16 810❘ 404 16 808 16 S.CT. (v) 8. Ct. Rep. 16 16 16 S. Ct. U. S. 8. Ct. U. S. 8. Ct. U. S. 8. Ct. U. 8. U. S. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. 1 16 1054 169 1002 353 16 1104 611 16 1207 682 16 1200 695 16 1203 705 16 1199 31 16 917 205 1016 369 16 1171 612 16 1168 683 16 1200 695 16 1204 705 16 1206 49 16 911 207 1023 376 16 986 618 16 1159 684 16 1200 696 16 56 16 914 228 977 385 16 1148 625 16 1073 685 16 1.200 696 16 63 16 939 244 993 416 16 1113 631 16 1076 685 16 1201 697 16 75 16 969 258 998 427 16 1120 632 16 1127 686 16 1201 697 16 81 16 1031 269 967 445 16 1101 632 16 1197 687 16 1201 697 16 93 16 975 273 1051 452 16 1112 662 16 1192 687 16 1202 698 16 100 16 1017 280 1020 456 16 1082 675 16 1198 688 16 1201 699 16 101 16 990 289 1047 468 16 1064 676 16 1198 688 16 1202 700 16 109 16 1036 299 1086 485 1109 677 16 1198 689 16 1202 700 16 118 16 1042 319 1120 491 1093 678 16 1198 690 16 1202 701 16 132 16 983 321 1018 499 1071 678 16 1199 691 16 1202 703 16 140 16 961 325 1039 504 1076 679 16 1199 692 16 1203 703 16 142 16 1096 331 963 520 1162 680 16 1199 693 16 1203 703 16 155 16 961 342 1017 537 1138 681 16 1199 694 16 1203 704 16 160 18 971 346 1117 564 1173 681 16 1200 16 16 1204 706 16 1199 1207 16 16 U. 8. 8. Ct. Rep. Rep. U. S. 16 16 16 16 16 8. Ct. 8. Ct. Rep. 1208 16 S.CT. (vi) 16 16 - GRAS.NU Kim NT NTUK BP CASES REPORTED. Page Abbeville County. Folsom v. (159 U. S. .1202 Ainsa v. United States (161 U. S. 208). 544 Alberty v. United States (162 U. S. 499).. 864 Albuquerque Hotel & Opera House Co., Medler v. (163 U. S. 695). Allen v. Cannon (163 U. S. 675). Allen, United States v. (163 U. S. 499)...1071 Allianca, The (163 U. S. 690). Allison v. United States (160 U. S. 203).. 252 American Bell Tel. Co., United States v. .1202 69 1204 .1198 (159 U. S. 548). American Dock & Improvement Co. v. City .1198 .1199 of Jersey City (163 U. S. 675). American Sugar Refining Co., The Centurion v. (163 U. S. 705)... American Waterworks Co. of Illinois v. Farmers' Loan & Trust Co. (163 U. S. 675) Andrews v. Thum (163 U. S. 676). Andrews v. United States (162 U. S. 420) 798 Ansbro v. United States (159 U. S. 695).. 187 Arnold, United States v. (163 U. S. 709)..1208 Aslesen v. State of Minnesota (163 U. S. 676) Atchison, T. & S. F. R. Co. v. Mulligan .... (163 U. S. 676). .1198 .1198 Aulick, United States v. (163 U. S. 709)..1207 Ayers, First Nat. Bank of Garnett v. (160 U. S. 660).... 412 1198 .1198 853 554 Baca v. United States (163 U. S. 676)....1198 .1192 105 1198 .1198 Baltimore & O. R. Co. v. Sutherland (163 U. S. 676).... Baltimore & O. & C. R. Co. v. Yarde (163) U. S. 677)... Baltzer v. State of North Carolina (161 U. S. 240). 500 Baltzer v. State of North Carolina (161 U. S. 246). 502 Bamberger v. Schoolfield (160 U. S. 149).. 225 Bank of Commerce v. State of Tennessee, two cases (161 U. S. 134)... Bank of Commerce v. State of Tennessee, two cases (163 U. S. 416). 456 Barber v. Isaacs (163 U. S. 677).. .1113 .1198 Barber Asphalt Paving Co. v. City of Harrisburg (163 U. S. 677). ... .1198 .1042 135 837 334 1201 Beverly, Barnitz v. (163 U. S. 118). Barnitz v. Beverly (163 U. S. 118). S. v.168.c. Beall, Dushane v. (161 U. S. 513).. Beebe v. United States (161 U. S. 104). Bertha Zine & Mineral Co. v. Carrico (163) ... ... ** Page 637 .1201 532 443 939 .1016 ... Blagge v. Balch (162 U. S. 439). 34 571 803 72 853 29 644 .1159 875 585 Booth v. Crawford (163 U. S. 678). 803 802 804 278 .1199 182 .1198 .1042 .1199 S. .1101 853 454 .1206 321 492 .1206 .1206 1205 1199 Page .1198 Carrico, Bertha Zine & Mineral Co. v. (163 .1201 Carver v. United States (160 U. S. 553).. 388 Cavanaugh, Northern Pac. R. Co. v. (163 U. S. 698). Caverly v. Deere & Co. (163 U. S. 679)...1199 Ceballos v. The Warren Adams (163 U. S. 679) .1204 .1199 Central Land Co. of West Virginia v. Laid- Central Pac. R. Co. v. State of Nevada .1206 Central Railroad & Banking Co. of Georgia, Southwestern R. Co. v. (163 U. S. 705) Central Trust Co. of New York v. Richmond, N. I. & B. R. Co. (163 U. S. 679)..1199 Central Vermont R. Co., Rutland R. Co. v., two cases (159 U. S. 630). Centurion, The, v. American Sugar Refining Co. (163 U. S. 705). 113 .1199 Ceres, The, v. Wessels (163 U. S. 706)....1199 Certain Real Estate known as the "Church Farm" v. United States (163 U. S. 680)..1199 Certain Real Estate known as the "Coal Lands" v. United States (163 U. S. 680)..1199 Certain Real Estate known as the "Gardo ..1199 House" v. United States (163 U. S. 680)..1199 Certain Real Estate known as the "Tithing Yard and Offices," United States v. (163) U. S. 680).. Certain Tract of Land in Cumberland Tp., United States v. (United States v. Gettysburg Electric R. Co., 160 U. S. 668). 427 Champion Min. Co., Walrath v. (163 U. S. 710) .1208 Chandler, Spalding v. (160 U. S. 394). 360 Chappell v. United States (160 U. S. 499) 397 Charless, Northern Pac. R. Co. v. (162 U. S. 359). 848 .1208 .1199 ... 80 766 885 269 Charleston, Western Union Tel. Co. v. (163 Chaves, United States v. (159 U. S. 452) 417 Bank of Portage (160 U. S. 646)... Chemical Nat. Bank of Chicago v. Hartford Deposit Co. (161 U. S. 1)...... 439 Chester, Western Union Tel. Co. v. (163) U. S. 711). .1208 Chicago, M. & St. P. R. Co. v. United 26 .1173 1207 R. Co. v. (163 U. S. 611).. 917 & Trust Co. v. (163 U. S. 31). Chicago, R. I. & P. R. Co. v. Stahley (163 U. S. 680). .1199 Chicago, R. I. & P. R. Co., Union Pac. R. Co. v. (163 U. S. 611).. .1207 Chicago, St. P., M. & O. R. Co., Burfenning v. (163 U. S. 321).... Chilton, Union Pac. R. Co. v. (163 U. S. 708) Chin Yuen Sing v. Kilbreth (163 U. S. 680) Chippewa Iron Co., Piper v., two cases (163 U. S. 700).. 53 57 .1018 .1207 .1199 .1204 Choppin, Forman v. (163 U. S. 686).. .1201 1203 U. S. 283). 828 City of Columbus, Miss., v. Dennison (163 City of Detroit, Detroit Citizens' St. R. .1203 ....... .1200 613 City of Harrisburg, Barber Asphalt Paving .1198 City of Jersey City, American Dock & Im- City of New Orleans v. United States (163 .1200 .1204 125 454 853 City of New Orleans, New Orleans C. & L. R. Co. v. (163 U. S. 697). City of Ogden, Hamer v. (163 U. S. 689)..1202 Clarkson v. Farmers' Loan & Trust Co. (163 U. S. 675). .1198 Cloughley, Rouse v. (163 U. S. 702).....1205 Cloyd, Wheeler v. (163 U. S. 711). .1208 Clune v. United States (159 U. S. 590). Cochran v. Blout (161 U. S. 350). Codman, Brooks v. (162 U. S. 439). Coeur D'Alene R. & Nav. Co., Washington & I. R. Co. v. (160 U. S. 77). Coeur D'Alene R. & Nav. Co., Washington & I. R. Co. v. (160 U. S. 101). Coffin v. United States (162 U. S. 664). 943 Collins, Wayne Lumber Co. v. (163 U. S. 711) .1208 Colorado Eastern R. Co., Union Pac. R. Co. v. (163 U. S. 708).. ..1207 Columbia v. Lyon (161 U. S. 200). Columbia, Washington Gaslight Co. v. (161 U. S. 316). 231 239 450 564 Columbus, Miss., v. Dennison (163 U. S. 695) .1200 ...1203 Comitiz v. Parkerson (163 U. S. 681). .1200 Commissioner of Patents, Du Bois v. (163 U. S. 684). Commonwealth of Kentucky, Louisville & N. R. Co. v. (161 U. S. 677). Conitiz v. Parkerson (163 U. S. 681). ..1200 Conlin, Oregon Short Line & U. N. R. Co. v. (162 U. S. 498). 714 Connecticut, Geer v. (161 U. S. 519). Cook v. Eells (163 U. S. 681). Cooper, Girard Life Insurance, Annuity & Cornell v. Green (163 U. S. 75). 871 600 497 914 75 .1204 .1200 .1200 879 879 .1117 969 .1200 28 456 |