Entered according to act of Congress, in the year one thousand nine hundred and three,

By J. B. LYON COMPANY,
in the office of the Librarian of Congress, at Washington.

Bec. Apr. S. 1908. .

J. B. LYON COMPANY,
PRINTERS, ELECTROTYPERS AND BINDERS,

LYON BLOCK, ALBANY, N. Y.

OF

THE APPELLATE DIVISION OF THE SUPREME COURT.

66

66

First Department.
HON. CHAS. H. VAN BRUNT, P.J.

EDWARD PATTERSON.
MORGAN J. O'BRIEN.
GEORGE L. INGRAHAM.
CHESTER B. MOLAUGHLIN.
EDWARD W. HATCH.

FRANK C. LAUGHLIN.
Second Department.
Hon. WILLIAM W. GOODRICH, P. J.

WILLARD BARTLETT.
JOHN WOODWARD.
MICHAEL H. HIRSCHBERG.
ALMET F. JENKS.

WARREN B. HOOKER.*
Third Department,
Hon. CHARLES E. PARKER, P. J.

WALTER LLOYD SMITH.
S. ALONZO KELLOGG.
EMORY A. CHASE.
ALDEN CHESTER.

Fourth Department,
Hon. WILLIAM H. ADAMS, P. J.

PETER B. MOLENNAN.
ALFRED SPRING.
PARDON C. WILLIAMS.
FRANK H. HISCOCK.

JOHN M. DAVY. * Designated by the Governor on December 8, 1902, to sit temporarily. + Designated by the Governor on December 30, 1901, to sit temporarily. Designation revoked in May, 1902. Again designated to sit temporarily September 23, 1902.

CAUSES in which the decisions contained in the Appellate

Division Reports have been passed upon by the Court of Appeals.

BANTA O. MERCHANT......

45 App. Div. 141 Judgment reversed : 173 N. Y. 292. BREED v. RUOFF...

71 App. Div. 621 Judgment reversed: 173 N. Y. 340. CHAUVET O. IVES.....

62 App. Div. 339 Judgment affirmed : 173 N. Y. 192. CITIZENS' BANK 0. TOWN OF GREENBURGH...

60 App. Div. 225 Judgment reversed : 173 N. Y. 215. CONKLING O. WEATHERWAX

66 App. Div. 617 Judgment reversed : 173 N. Y. 43. CONTINENTAL BANK O. TRADESMEN'S BANK...

.... 59 App. Div. 103 Judgment affirmed : 173 N. Y. 272. CRAWFORD 0. Nassoy.......

55 App. Div. 433 Order reversed : 173 N. Y. 163. DEVITT 0. PROVIDENCE WASHINGTON INs. Co...

61 App. Div. 390 Judgment affirmed : 173 N. Y. 17. Dinox 0. N. Y. C. & H. R. R. R. Co.....

74 App. Div. 626 Judgment affirmed : 173 N. Y. 356. FARMERS' FEED Co. o. SCOTTISH UNION INs. Co......

65 App. Div. 70 Judgment reversed : 173 N. Y. 241. HAMILTON O. CITY OF BUFFALO.....

55 App. Div. 423 Order reversed : 173 N. Y. 72. I. W. BREWING Co. v. BROOKLYN WHARF Co...

59 App. Div. 83 Appeal dismissed : 173 N. Y. 167. JOHNSON O. N. Y. C. & H. R. R. R. Co.....

66 App. Div. 617 Judgment reversed : 173 N. Y. 79. LEONARD 0. HARNEY..

63 App. Div. 294 Order modified : 173 N. Y. 352. MALONEY O. IROQUOIS BREWING CO......

63 App. Div. 454 Judgment reversed : 173 N. Y. 303. MATTER OF BAKER..

59 App. Div. 625 Order affirmed : 173 N. Y. 249. MATTER OF BOERUM STREET..

74 App. Div. 632 Appeal dismissed : 173 N. Y. 321. MATTER OF SHELDON...

72 App. Div. 625 Orders affirmed : 173 N. Y. 287. MEGOWAN v. PETERSON........

61 App. Div. 622 Judgment reversed : 173 N. Y. 1. N. Y. & N. H. SPRINKLER Co. v. ANDREWS.

62 App. Div. 8 Order affirmed : 173 N. Y. 25. N. Y. & ROSENDALE CEMENT CO, 0. KEATOR....

... 62 App. Div. 577 Judgment affirmed : 173 N. Y. 235.