(NEW YORK STATE REPORTER, VOL. 157)

CONTAINING THE DECISIONS OF THE

SUPREME AND LOWER COURTS OF RECORD

OF NEW YORK STATE

WITH TABLE OF NEW YORK SUPPLEMENT CASES THAT HAVE
BEEN PASSED UPON BY THE COURT OF APPEALS

AND
TABLE OF STATUTES CONSTRUED

KF
135
N4

JUNE 20- AUGUST 8, 1910

1:13

ST. PAUL
WEST PUBLISHING CO.

1910

THE

COPYRIGHT, 1910

BY

WEST PUBLISHING COMPANY

(123 N.Y.8.)

JUDGES

OP

THE COURTS REPORTED DURING THE PERIOD

COVERED BY THIS VOLUME

SUPREME COURT—First Department.

Justices of the Appellate Division.

GEORGE L. INGRAHAM, PRESIDING JUSTICE.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
OHESTER B. MCLAUGHLIN. JAMES W. HOUGHTON. 1
FRANK O. LAUGHLIN.

FRANCIS M. SCOTT.
JOHN PROCTOR CLARKE.

VICTOR J. DOWLING.
NATHAN L MILLER.2

First Department-Cont'd.

Justices of the First District. EDWARD B. WHITNEY.

JOHN J. BRADY. FRANCIS M. SCOTT.

CHARLES W. DAYTON. JAMES FITZGERALD.

MITCHELL L. ERLANGER. JAMES A. O'GORMAN,

JOHN FORD. P. HENRY DUGR0.

LEONARD A. GIEGERICH. JAMES A. BLANCHARD.

JOHN W. GOFF. JOHN PROCTOR CLARKE.

CHARLES L. GUY. SAMUEL GREENBAUM.

PETER A. HENDRICK. EDWARD B. AMEND.

M. WARLEY PLATZEK. VERNON M. DAVIS.

SAMUEL SEABURY. EDWARD E. MCCALL.

JAMES W. GERARD. HENRY BISCHOFF.

IRVING LEHMAN. VICTOR J. DOWLING..

NATHAN BIJUR.
JOSEPH E. NEWBURGER.

EDWARD J. GAVEGAN.
ALFRED R. PAGE.

Second Department.
Justices of the Appellate Division.
MICHAEL H. HIRSCHBERG, PRESIDING JUSTICE.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
JOHN WOODWARD.

NATHAN L. MILLER.2 ALMET F. JENKS.

EDWARD B. THOMAS. WARREN B. HOOKER.3

ADELBERT P. RICH. JOSEPH A. BURR. 4

WILLIAM J. CARR.5

Justices of the Second District. HARRINGTON PUTNAM.

WILLIAM J. CARR.B GARRET J. GARRETSON.

LESTER W. CLARK. SAMUEL T. MADDOX.

FREDERICK E. CRANE. ALMET F. JENKS.

WALTER H. JAYCOX. JOSIAH T. MAREAN.

TOWNSEND SCUDDER. WILLIAM J. KELLY.

EDWARD B. THOMAS. JOSEPH A. BURR.4

ABEL E. BLACKMAR.
JOSEPH ASPINALL.

LUKE D. STAPLETON.
ISAAC M. KAPPER.

Justices of the Ninth District. MARTIN J. KEOGH.

ISAAC N. MILLS. MICHAEL H. HIRSCHBERG. JOSEPH MORSCHAUSER.

ARTHUR S. TOMPKINS.

• Assigned to Appellate Division, First Department, to succeed James W. Houghton. • Term expired. * Assigned to Appellate Division, Second Department. • Temporarily designated to Appellate Division, Second Department.