DECIDED IN

THE COURT OF SESSION,

COURT OF JUSTICIARY,

AND

HOUSE OF LORDS,

FROM AUGUST 10, 1888, TO AUGUST 8, 1889.

REPORTED BY

MIDDLETON RETTIE, JAMES PATTEN, C. C. MACONOCHIE,
H. J. E. FRASER, AND JOHN DAVID SYM,

ESQUIRES, ADVOCATES.

FOURTH SERIES.-VOL. XVI.

EDINBURGH:

T. & T. CLARK, LAW BOOKSELLERS.

LONDON: STEVENS & SONS.

M.DCCC.LXXXIX.