PEOPLE V. MANHATTAN REAL ESTATE Co..... 74 App. Div. 535 Judgment reversed : 175 N. Y. 133. PEOPLE 0. ORANGE Co. Road Cons. Co..... 73 App. Div. 580 Order reversed : 175 N. Y. 84. PEOPLE 0. STEDEKER. 75 App. Div. 449 Order reversed : 175 N. Y, 57. PODMORE 0. SOUTH BROOKLYN Sav. INST..... 67 App. Div. 619 Judgment affirmed : 175 N. Y. 69. ROBINSON v. MANHATTAN RAILWAY Co...... 73 App. Div. 626 Judgment and order reversed : 175 N. Y. 219. SEIDENSPINNER O. MET. LIFE INs. Co....... 70 App. Div. 476 Judgment reversed : 175 N. Y. 95. SLATER 0. SLATER...... 78 App. Div. 449 Judgment modi fied and as modified affirmed : 175 N. Y. 143. STECHER LITHOGRAPHIC Co. v. INMAN... 67 App. Div. 625 Judgment affirmed : 175 N. Y. 124. STEPHENS 0. N. Y., O. & W. Ry. Co...... 61 App. Div. 612 Judgment reversed : 175 N. Y. 72. VAN ZANDT 0, GRANT..... 67 App. Div. 70 Judgment affirmed : 175 N. Y. 150. The of the profession is called to the fact that the Court of Appeals in many cases decides an appeal upon other grounds than those stated in the opinion of the court below. The affirmance or reversal of the judgment of the Appellate Division does not necessarily show that the Court of Appeals concurred in or dissented from, the statements contained in the opinion of the Supreme Court. (Rogers v. Decker, 131 N. Y. 490.) – REP. A TABLE OF THE NAMES OF THE CASES REPORTED IN THIS VOLUME PAGE. 644 A. PAGE. Abraham v. Burstein.... 631 Bennett v. Riley... 639, 645 Abruzzo, Liotta v.. 429 Bernstein, Segler v..... 267 Adams v. Metropolitan Street R. Bessenger v. Metropolitan Street Co....... 354 R. Co... 615 Adams, Robinson v.. 637 Bigham, La Marsh v..... 645 Adams, Thompson v. 569 Binninger v. City of New York... 645 Adams v. Wallace 117 Bisbop, Matter of...... 112 American Legion of Honor, Su- Blumenthal v. Lewy..... 535 preme Council, Davis v......... 645 Board of Education, Gunnison v... 645 American Legion of Honor, Su- Board of Fire Commissioners, Matpreme Council, Simons v... 617 ter of....... 636 Anderson, Matter of... 637 Boss v. Brooklyn Heights R. R. Co. 644 Anway, Jayne v... 640 Boston Insurance Co., Schmitt Appleton, McLaughlin v...... 234 Archibald v. Press Publishing Co. 513 Bough v. Metropolitan Street R. Arkenan Certificate (Matter of Cul. Co....... Brothers v. 215 linan)...... 643 Bowen, McWhirter v. 144 Asher, People v 637 Bowen, People v.. 637 Associazione Fraterna Italiana v.. Bowen v. Preferred Accident Ins. Gobbi..... 635 Co....... 458 Boyd v. Gernant. 456 B. Brady, Koehler & Co. V..... 279, 636 Bach, Smith v..... 608 Brandt v. Morning Journal Assn.. 636 Baker, People ex rel., v. Collier... 644 Brennan, People ex rel., v. ScanBall v. Heissenbuttel 644 644 Barefield, Matter of.... 463 Bretsch v. Plate... 399 Barry v. Metropolitan Street R. Co. 636 Brewer, Harvey v. 589 Bartlett v. Bartlett.. 637 Bridgman v. Brooklyn Heights R. Bateman v. Straus.. 645 R. Co...... 645 Bauer v. Parker.. 289 Brien v. Stone. 450 Bauland Co., Rush v. 506 Brockner, Mead v. 480 Beattie v. Callanan... 7 Brodsky, German Savings Bank v. 635 Benedict, Ward v 636 Brooklyn Heights R. R. Co., Boss Bennett, Cornish v. 636 v.... 644 vii man v...... V..... V Brooklyn Heights R. R. Co., Bridg. City of New York, Simpson v.... 637 645 City of New York, Thilemann v.. 136 Brooklyn Heights R. R. Co., Con. City of New York, Wenk v...... 584 way V..... 516 City of Yonkers, Culver v........ 645 Brooklyn Heights R. R. Co., Free City of Yonkers, Harriman v...... 408 man v....... 521 Clancy v. N. Y. & Queens County Brooklyn Heights R. R. Co., Gil R. Co. (2 cases)....... 563 lespie v. 645 Clark v. Erie R. R. Co.. 646 Brooklyn Heights R. R. Co., Clark, Ogden v... 635 O'Reilly v.. 492, 643 Clarke v. Gleylman.. 636 Brooklyn Heights R. R. Co., Schun Clarke, Williams v.. 199 560 Cohen, People ex rel., v. Cantor... 636 Brooklyn Heights R. R. Co., Smith Colby, Matter of, v. Partridge. 637 531 | Coleman v. Metropolitan Street R. Brooklyn Union El. R. R. Co., Co.... 435 Matter of....... 567 Collier, People ex rel. Baker v..... 644 Brooklyn Union Gas Co., People ex Collier, People ex rel. Colne v..... 644 rel., v. Feitner. 368 Collier, People ex rel. Daniels v.... 644 "Brown, Fleming v. (2 cases). 636 Collier, People ex rel. Meyer v..... 644 Brown v. Jones... 645 Collier, People ex rel. Morgan v... 644 Brown v. Manhattan Railway Co.. 222 Collier, People ex rel. Murphy v... 644 Brown, Williams v. 353 Collins Building & Construction Buck, Van Arsdale v. 383 Co., White v...... 1 Buckhout v. City of New York... 218 Colne, People ex rel., v. Collier.... 644 Buckley, Lynch v. 614 Comerford v. Smith. 638 Burke v. Rhoads. 325 Condict v. Long Beach Land Co... 645 Burstein, Abraham V....... 631 Constable v. Rosener.. 155 Burton, Walworth Mfg. Co. v..... 637 Conte v. Conte..... 335 516 Cahn v. Hatch..... 636 Coolot Co., Kahner & Co. v.. 637 Callaghan, Lundine v. 621 Cornish v. Bennett.. 636 Callanan, Beattie v... 7 Cowles, Citizens' State Bank v... 645 Campbell, Piper v... 643 Cox v. Halloran.. 639 Canter, Matter of... 103 Cronin, Fuhr v..... 210 Cantor, People ex rel. Cohen v.... 636 Cronin v. Metropolitan Street R. Co. 227 Carena v. Zanmatti ... 11 Cruikshank, Matter of.... 645 Chesebrough, Smith v. 578 Cullinan, Matter of (Arkenan CerChisolm v. Toplitz..... 346 tificate).. 643 Christianson v. O'Neill ..., 635 Cullinan, Matter of (Jacobs CerCitizens' State Bank v. Cowles.... 645 tificate)... 643 City of New York, Bindinger v... 645 Cullinan, Matter of (Johnson CerCity of New York, Buckhout v... 218 tificate).. 643 City of New York, France v. 637 Cullinan, Matter of (Kojan CerCity of New York, Halpin v...... 311 tificate)... 613 City of New York, Link v. 486 Cullinan, Matter of (Koster CerCity of New York, Lyons v. 306 tificate)... 643 City of New York, Martin v...... 35 Cullinan, Matter of (Kray Cer 445 471 City of New York, Milliken v tificate)... Cullinan, Matter of (Strauss Сer. Fay, Matter of, v. Partridge...... 637 tificate) 643 Feitner, People ex rel. Brooklyn Cullinan v. Waldron 637 368 Culver v. City of Yonkers.. 645 Fernandez, Kohly v. (2 cases)...... 636 Curry, McGlynn v.. 431 Feuchtwanger, Matter of Reinach v. 636 Feuerstein, Moore v. 645 D. Flamm v. Perry... 646 D'Arcy v. Westchester Electric R. Fleming v. Brown (2 cases).. 636 Co 263 Fleming, Matter of....... 635 Daniels, People ex rel., v. Collier... 644 Flick v. Penfield. (Nos. 1 & 2).... 610 Davis v. Supreme Council.... 645 Foley, Haynes v.. 629 Delano, Matter of... 147 Forsatti v. Poyet. 635 Democratic General Committee, Fort Washington Ridge Road (Mat. People ex rel. Garvey v.... 173 ter of Mayor)...... 163 Denike, Mesnier v... 404 Foster, People ex rel., v. York.... 637 Diebold v. Walter 637 France v. City of New York 637 Dike, Saffier v..... 485 Franklin v. Judson... 636 Dime Savings Bank of Brooklyn, Fraser, Kieley v... 636 Podmore v.... 637 Freeman v. Brooklyn Heights R. R. Dimon, Matter of.. 107 Co..... 521 Dineen v. Hughes..... 644 Frost v. Hoe.... 637 Dolfini v. Erie R. R. Co.. 643 Fuhr v. Cronin.. 210 Donner v. Mercy... 637 Fuller Co., Walters v..... 254 Dowling V. Nassau Electric R. R. Co.... 643 G. Downes v. Elmira Bridge Co.. 639 Galloway, Grosjean v. 380 Drew, Magnolia Metal Co. v... 635, 636 Garvey, People ex rel., v. DemoDubey, People ex rel., v. Swan. cratic Committee. 173 strom... 645 374 Duffy, Ramell v. 496 Gebhardt, People ex rel., v. PartDuggan v. Phelps. ridge.... 636 Dunlop v. Mulry.. 637 German Savings Bank v. Brodsky.. 635 Dykman v. United States Life Gernant, Boyd v.... 456 Ins. Co..... 645 643 E. Gibbs v. New York Press Co.(Ltd.). 636 Eggers, Goldbacher v. 637 Gillen, People ex rel., v. Partridge. 644 Elmira Bridge Co., Downes v..... 639 Gillespie v. Brooklyn Heights R. R. 637 Co.. Endelman, Skillin v... 645 Erie R. R. Co., Clark v. 616 186 Erie R. R. Co., Dolfini v.... 643 Gobbi, Associazione Fraterna Ital. Erie R. R. Co., Hudson v. iana v 635 Esselstyn v. Union Surety & Guar- Goetzinger, Matter of.. 614 637 anty Co....... 474 Goldbacher v. Eggers.. Excelsior Brewing Co., Meinhardt Golob v. Pasinsky 637 v.. 65 627 Goodsell v. Goodsell.. 316 439 Fallon v. Wright... 193 Grant Avenue, Matter of. 636 Farrar v Kane.. 636 | Graves v. Metropolitan Street R. Co. 636 Klinder v. New York Breweries Horikoshi, Kennedy v 415 Co........ 509 643 PAGE PAGE. Great South Bay Water Co., Smith Hughes, Dineen v. 644 V...... 427 Hughes v. Jones 643 Griffon Co., Kraft v.. 29 Husted, Wood v. 644 Grifhahn v. Kreizer 645 Grosjean v. Galloway. 380 I. Gunn, Hammel v... 645 Interurban Street R. Co., LaGunnison v. Board of Education .. 645 penta v... 643 Gunser v. New York & Queens Interurban Street R. Co., Schmidt County R. Co.... 644 453 Guttentag v. Whitney.. 145 Irvin, People v. 636 V...... V.... H. J. Hackett, People 86 Jacobs Certificate (Matter of CulHaight v. Stock, Grain & Provision linan)..... 643 Co. of New York. 637 | Jarvie, Lurman v.. 37 Halloran, Cox v... 639 Jayne v. Anway.. 640 Halpin v. City of New York. 311 Johnson Certificate (Matter of Cul. Hamblet v. Hamblet.. 636 linan)... 643 Hammel v. Gunn... 645 Jones, Brown v 645 Happ v. Lauffer.. 645 Jones, Hughes v.. 643 Harms v. Horgan. 636 Joseph v. Raff.. 47 Harriman v. City of Yonkers. 408 Judson, Franklin v..... 636 Hart v. Myers... 637 Harvey v. Brewer. 589 K. Hatch, Cahn v 636 Kahner & Co. v. Coolot Co........ 637 Hatzel v. Moore..... 635 636 Havana Bridge Co., Wallace v.... 646 Kappus v. Metropolitan Street R. Hawkins v. Mapes-Reeve Construc Co. 13 tion Co....... 72 Karsch v. Pottier & Stymus Mfg., Haynes v. Foley... 629 230 Hayward, Reed v.. 416 Kay, Matter of (In re Walton Ave.). 636 Heissenbuttel, Ball v.. 644 Kay, People ex rel., v. Swanstrom. 645 Henderson, Theime v. 566 503 Herbst, Miller v 634 Kells v. People's Trust Co........ 548 Herlin v. Masury & Son.. 645 Kellum v. Mission of Immaculate Herrmann v. Herrmann. 437 523 Heylman, Clarke v..... 636 Kennedy v. Horikoshi.. 415 Hitchings, People ex rel., v. Van Kessler, Kinkel v 643 de Carr..... 637 636 Hoe, Frost v. 637 643 Hoelter v. McDonald 423 413 Hogan, Thornton v..... 500 411 Horgan, Harms v. 636 637 House v. Yonkers R. R. Co... 614 Knights of Pythias, Supreme Lodge, Hudler v. Metropolitan St. R. Co.. 644 Meyer V......... 359 Hudson v. Erie R. R. Co 643 Koehler & Co. v. Brady 279, 636 Hudson Valley R. Co., O'Sullivan Koffler v. Underhill.. 636 613 Kolily v. Fernandez (2 cases)...... 636 V., |